New heartthrob Robert Pattinson of Twilight fame and High School Musical’s Zac Efron wore identical Dolce & Gabbana tuxes to the Oscars… but they arrived on the red carpet looking very different.

Sexy Robert Pattinson — a.k.a. Edward Cullen, vampire extraordinaire — impressed the fashion critics with his tailored-yet-not-stiff look. The impeccable tux contrasted perfectly with Pattinson’s bronze, tousled hair and slightly scruffy facial hair. The phenom looked like anything but a newcomer as he made his way through the adoring crowd.

Handsome Zac Efron, on the other hand, paid tribute to Old Hollywood with slicked-back hair and a clean-shaven face. With gorgeous girlfriend, Vanessa Hudgens, on his arm, popular Efron had no trouble capturing the attention of an adoring crowd.

So who wore it better? Penguin suits sometimes give their wearers a certain “waiter” appeal, and Efron’s formal coif cemented that perception for me. The casual formal pulled off by Pattinson, on the other hand, makes him the clear winner.

I choose the vampire … how about you?

Nicole Kidman, step aside for some hot young stars. New talent ruled the red carpet at the 81st Annual Academy Awards. Here’s my pick for the top 5:

#5 Frieda Pinto — Frieda looked amazing in a royal blue John Galliano gown with sequined detailing. But does it really matter what this Slumdog Millionaire star wears?
Her natural beauty will always take center stage.

#4 Miley Cyrus — Looks like Hannah Montana finally got the message: dress your age!
After bombing out on so many red carpets in dresses that were far too old for her, Miley finally got it right. She wore a sparkly Zuhair Murad ball gown in ivory silk chiffon. The beaded v-neck bodice and tiered skirt were perfect for a teen sensation.

#3 Vanessa Hudgens — This was no High School
Musical prom for Vanessa. She “felt like a young Audrey
Hepburne” in her curve-hugging, black Marchesa gown.
The ruched, sequined, flower-embellished confection
looked gorgeous with her soft, effortless up-do. And her
date, Zac Efron, was perhaps her very best accessory!

#2 Natalie Portman — This talented young star continues to wow us on and off the screen. She carries herself with tremendous grace yet doesn’t try to look older than she is. Natalie’s simple Rodarte strapless dress in bubble gum pink was youthful and elegant.

#1 Amanda Seyfried — TheMamma Mia star looked amazing in a brick red Valentino gown. While you usually find this designer’s duds on more mature stars, Amanda used the fabulous color and a big bow embellishment to make it perfectly age appropriate. She’s my winner for this year’s red carpet.

Next: Check out my nominees for the top young guys on the red carpet.

Who’s your number one red carpet pick?

Photos: Oscars.com